config/hardware.example.ini

@@ -69,26 +69,6 @@ cameras = rgb
 device = /dev/serial/by-id/usb-Arduino_LLC_Arduino_Leonardo-if00
 baud   = 115200
 
-[Pins]
-; How the MCU is wired to each axis's TMC5160 driver board. The host never sends
-; these: the FIRMWARE is built from them. firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py reads this
-; section from the tower's own copy of this file when the firmware is built on
-; the tower, and refuses pins the board cannot use. Change a wire, change this,
-; rebuild and re-flash. `test hardware motor` compares it with what the running
-; firmware reports, so a flash built from an older copy shows up there.
-;
-; The reference loom for each board, with the MCU-pin -> driver-pin table, is in
-; hardware/<board>/pins.ini.
-;
-; Leonardo (Delta): SPI is fixed on the ICSP header, so only CS and EN are named.
-; RP2040 (IOTA): also spi_sck / spi_mosi / spi_miso, from SPI0's pin groups -
-;   SCK {2,6,18,22}  MOSI {3,7,19,23}  MISO {0,4,16,20}
-; Only axes listed in [Hardware] axes get pins.
-yaw_cs   = 8
-yaw_en   = 7
-pitch_cs = 1
-pitch_en = 0
-
 [IMU]
 ; Only read when [Hardware] imu is not 'none'. On the LattePanda 3 Delta the MTi
 ; is on the RS-232 header, which is a hardware UART: a stable /dev/ttyS* node,

docs/hardware-config-plan.md

@@ -227,7 +227,7 @@ this whole design is removing. Make it an explicit act.
 
 Only **pin assignments** and the **axis count**: pins because SPI must be up before anything can be
 asked or answered, the axis count because it sizes the axis array. Both are still defined once in
-`hardware.ini` (`[Pins]`, `[Hardware] axes`) and *generated* into `board_wiring.h` at build — one definition, realised at build
+`hardware.ini` and *generated* into `firmware/src/config.h` at build — one definition, realised at build
 time instead of over the wire. Everything else becomes runtime, which shrinks the build-time set far
 below what I proposed last turn.
 
@@ -402,27 +402,6 @@ Deploy host-before-firmware (A.6). Fix the `Application.cpp:1040` literals in th
 existing fleet that drops yaw 50000 → 30000, a real behaviour change that wants a deliberate rig check
 rather than a silent correction.
 
-> ### ⚠️ The Delta fleet is NOT migrated, and flashing it first would strand it
->
-> Checked 2026-09-23: tower **111 has no `/etc/fire_gimbal_control/hardware.ini`**.
-> Only tower 121 has been migrated. This is a live hazard rather than a leftover
-> chore, because the firmware half is now written: **an axis with no declared
-> drivetrain sits in `NEEDCFG` and refuses to move.** Flashing 111 with current
-> firmware today would leave it unable to home, with nothing wrong that an
-> operator could see on the board.
->
-> The ordering rule above is what prevents it, and it is not advisory:
->
-> 1. Write 111 a `hardware.ini` — `hardware/lattepanda-iota/install.sh --stdout`
->    generates the shape; the Delta's own values come from its `config.ini`.
-> 2. Deploy the **host** and run `test hardware`. It must pass on the old
->    firmware, which is the point of the `_current`/`_declared` metrics reporting
->    an absent field as unconfirmable rather than as a mismatch.
-> 3. Only then flash the firmware, and re-run `test hardware`.
->
-> Until step 1 is done for every Delta tower, phase 1's gate — "`test hardware`
-> green on every existing tower" — is **not met**, whatever 121 reports.
-
 ## 14. Firmware changes, collected
 
 - **Per board** → `platform_leonardo.h` / `platform_iota.h`: pin map plus the three AVR-isms
@@ -466,7 +445,6 @@ after the table.
 | 6  | Config handshake — **firmware half** | **done, and validated on tower 121.** `NEEDCFG` state (`ST` code `C`), `NEED` emitted with the banner, `SET <axis> <key> <value>`, `USE DEFAULTS`, and the init block split so the residual-motion stop still runs at boot. 33 native tests pass under `pio test -e native`. On the rig: the handshake was watched live, `HOME` refused with `ERR need config`, `RESET` did not escape the state, and `USE DEFAULTS` released it |
 | 6  | Adoption check generalised | **done**, 9 tests. `DUMP` echoes every host-owned value plus a `cfg_rx` bitmask; `test hardware motor` checks all of them, and reports an absent field as unconfirmable rather than as a mismatch against -1. Round trip NEED -> SET -> DUMP -> PASS verified against `mock_needcfg` |
 | 14 | Drivetrain out of `MOTOR_CONFIG` | **done.** The struct keeps pins and `homing_kind` only; `platform_iota.h` keeps its measurement record but no longer defines this tower's values. `USE DEFAULTS` now loads a shared **limp-home** set (`LIMP_*` in `config.h`) that is deliberately nobody's real values — slow speeds, generous margins, the gentle search current — so a tower still running them fails `test hardware motor` instead of looking configured. `SW_MODE` is derived from `homing_kind` rather than shared, because disabling the hardware stops on an axis that homes on real switches would remove its last protection. Flash cost, not saved: see the porting plan. Found a real bug on the way — `DIAG` read `normal_speed` / `center_speed` from the compile-time table, so it ran at compiled speeds rather than the tower's declared ones |
-| 14 | Pins and `NUM_AXES` generated from `hardware.ini` | **done, validated on tower 121** (2026-09-23): built from its `/etc` file, flashed, `DUMP` echoed `spi=2,3,0 cs=1 en=4`, `IOIN version=0x30`, and `test hardware motor` passed `yaw_pins` / `spi_pins`; a build against a copy without `[Pins]` failed with the reason. Leonardo flash cost not yet measured. New `[Pins]` section; `firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py` generates `board_wiring.h` into the build directory from the tower's own file at build time, and refuses pins the board cannot use (RP2040 SPI0 groups, the Leonardo's fixed ICSP pins, duplicates, a board/env mismatch). No compiled-in fallback: no file or no `[Pins]` fails the build. `DUMP` echoes `cs=`/`en=` per axis and `spi=` on the RP2040; `test hardware motor` compares them with `[Pins]`. The loom tables moved to `hardware/<board>/pins.ini`. 18 generator tests (run without PlatformIO), 9 host tests |
 | 6  | `NEEDCFG` understood host-side | **done**, 5 tests. `AxisState::NeedConfig` parsed from `ST` `C`, named in `DUMP` and the dashboard, and counted as telemetry arriving rather than as a dead link. The firmware enum APPENDS the state (5) rather than inserting it — inserting renumbered every later state and made a READY axis read back as ERROR |
 
 **Validated on tower 121.** The handshake was watched live on the rig, not inferred:

docs/hardware-porting-plan.md

@@ -133,13 +133,11 @@ size or override it, or the filesystem/OTA layout will be wrong.
 >
 > So the **first** flash of a factory board needs the REPL trick or a physical
 > BOOTSEL press — one time per board, and worth knowing before someone drives to
-> a mast. **That one is still true.**
+> a mast. The **update** case is the one that still has no answer: our firmware
+> honours the 1200-baud reset but returns to the application, so a tower cannot
+> currently be re-flashed over the network at all.
 >
-> The **update** case was the one that had no answer at the time of that table:
+> **Fixed by a `BOOTSEL` serial command** calling arduino-pico's
-> our firmware honoured the 1200-baud reset but returned to the application, so a
-> tower could not be re-flashed over the network at all.
->
-> **Since fixed by a `BOOTSEL` serial command** calling arduino-pico's
 > `rp2040.rebootToBootloader()` — implemented and proven on tower 121 the same
 > day. The full loop now runs with nobody at the board:
 >
@@ -297,7 +295,7 @@ commit `aab1925`.
 
 | Phase | Item | State |
 |---|---|---|
-| 0 | Remote-flash question researched — two viable paths, design rule derived (§2) | **done, and solved** (§2). Both researched paths turned out not to work on the board; the answer was a `BOOTSEL` serial command, proven on tower 121 and now sent automatically by `firmware/deploy.sh` before every RP2040 upload. The **first** flash of a factory board still needs the MicroPython REPL or a physical BOOTSEL press — once per board |
+| 0 | Remote-flash question researched — two viable paths, design rule derived (§2) | **done, and now measured on the board: neither works** (§2). First flash needs the MicroPython REPL or BOOTSEL; remote *update* is unsolved pending a `BOOTSEL` command |
 | 2 | **Phase 2 gate: RP2040 + TMC5160-BOB at 3.3 V** | **PASSED** on tower 121, 2026-09-15: `IOIN Y=0x3000001E version=0x30`, encoder reading (`X_ENC`), one axis, `speed=3000` |
 | 2 | `src/platform.h` — reset cause and free RAM behind one interface per MCU family | **done** |
 | 2 | `Serial.begin()` moved ahead of all hardware init, so a wedged image stays flashable | **done** |
@@ -305,7 +303,7 @@ commit `aab1925`.
 | 2 | Per-board pin map + `NUM_AXES` in `platform_leonardo.h` / `platform_iota.h`, as-built wiring | **done** — compile-time, not yet generated from `hardware.ini` |
 | 2 | Pins + `NUM_AXES` generated from `hardware.ini` | **not started, no longer blocked** — the config plan it waited on is complete. The last open phase-2 item |
 | 3 | Yaw homing on the real drivetrain | **done** — the endstop was being sheared through at full torque; homing at 189 mA holds. See below |
-| 1 | Phase 1 in full — `hardware.ini`, the config handshake, presence reconciliation, `test hardware` | **built and validated on 121, NOT rolled out.** [hardware-config-plan.md](hardware-config-plan.md) is complete, but tower **111 has no `hardware.ini` at all** (checked 2026-09-23), so the gate ("`test hardware` green on every existing tower") is not met. Flashing a Delta before writing it one would strand the axis in `NEEDCFG` — see the migration warning in [the config plan §13](hardware-config-plan.md#13-migration) |
+| 1 | Phase 1 in full — `hardware.ini`, the config handshake, presence reconciliation, `test hardware` | **done.** [hardware-config-plan.md](hardware-config-plan.md) is complete and validated on tower 121; the gate ("`test hardware` green on every existing tower") is met on 121, and still wants running against the Delta fleet |
 
 > **Where the firmware gets built.** PlatformIO is not installed on the dev box; the firmware is built
 > *remotely on a tower* by `firmware/deploy.sh --compile-only`. Locally, the Arduino-free sources

docs/known-issues.md

@@ -31,7 +31,7 @@ doctest unit-test suite (`ctest`).
 | 14 | Capture sweep on hardware | **Mechanically verified on the rig (2026-08-07).** A full `--init --start` run homed both axes and completed `MOVE → settle → trigger` for 15/15 waypoints with 0 dropped frames, 0 stalls and 0 acquisition failures. `kSettleTolCounts` (600) and the per-interval timing in [CaptureScheduler.cpp](../src/core/CaptureScheduler.cpp) have **not** been tuned against observed `ST` behaviour yet, and the settle tolerance has not been checked against a sharp image (see #16). |
 | 15 | **Camera profiles unverified on a lit scene** | The `standard`/`night` profiles must be exported from the VimbaX Viewer (see `config/camera_profiles/rgb/README.md`) and have not been measured against real light. Confirm on the rig that `LoadSettings` succeeds, that `standard` sustains 10 fps with `frames_dropped` at 0, and that the auto-exposure lands on a sensible `ExposureTime` outdoors. The only previous rig test ran with the lens covered. |
 | 16 | **`settle_wait_ms` untuned** | `standard` waits 1 s and `night` 2.5 s after standstill before keeping a frame. Both are reasoned (≫ one frame period; long enough for the auto-exposure to see the new scene) but not measured. Check on a lit scene that the kept frame shows no slew blur and that its exposure has actually converged for that heading, and shorten the wait if it has. |
-| 19 | **USB preconditions do not survive a reboot** | `usbcore.usbfs_memory_mb` reverts to 16 (needs 1000) and USB3 LPM re-enables on the camera's port. **Both were wrong on the LattePanda when tested on 2026-08-07**, and frame delivery stalls without them regardless of application code. **Solved on tower 121 by the setup kit** (`hardware/lattepanda-iota/preconditions/`): a systemd-tmpfiles drop-in for usbfs and two udev rules, all installed by `install.sh --preconditions`. Verified 2026-09-23 — `usbfs_memory_mb` reads 1000 after **6 days of uptime**, so it survived the boot, and both rules are in `/etc/udev/rules.d/`. Note it is **tmpfiles, not the kernel cmdline** the original entry proposed. **Still open on the Delta fleet**, which has not had the kit applied. |
+| 19 | **USB preconditions do not survive a reboot** | `usbcore.usbfs_memory_mb` reverts to 16 (needs 1000) and USB3 LPM re-enables on the camera's port. **Both were wrong on the LattePanda when tested on 2026-08-07**, and frame delivery stalls without them regardless of application code. Needs the udev rule + kernel cmdline persistence described under *Camera acquisition* below. |
 
 ## Camera acquisition (USB3) — root cause + approach
 
@@ -100,18 +100,6 @@ scripts for this are worth keeping; note that wrapping them in `timeout` SIGTERM
   and real motor captured 15/15 waypoints, one software-triggered frame each, 0 dropped and 0 stalls. What
   this does **not** cover is image *content* — the lens was covered, so exposure/blur behaviour on a real
   scene remains open (#15–#17).
-- **Log rotation verified on the rig (2026-09-23); pruning is not.** With
-  `[Logging] file_max_mb = 1` on tower 121, a segment closed at 1048513 bytes against
-  the 1048576 cap — rotating *before* the write that would cross it, on a whole line —
-  and the next segment re-emitted the header. Retention (`file_keep`) needs a fourth
-  segment to observe a deletion, roughly three hours at that cap, and was not run.
-  `tests/test_filelogsink.cpp` covers it directly.
-- **The positive-travel guard has never fired in anger.** `checkTravelFitsPositive()`
-  catches a `center_count` smaller than half the homed travel, which puts the negative
-  end below zero. It was tested against real numbers and shipped *after* 121's centre
-  was raised to 1000000, so no tower has ever tripped it. Whether the TMC5160 actually
-  misbehaves below zero is still not established — see the note in
-  `include/fgc/HardwareChecks.h`.
 - **Makefile parity** is moot: the Makefile was removed in favour of CMake, and the full
   `WITH_VIMBA=ON WITH_MQTT=ON` CMake build now runs on the device.
 - **Demo mode** copies `bin/x64/Release/test_smoke.jxl`, resolved relative to the working directory. Run from a

docs/roadmap.md

@@ -18,15 +18,6 @@ Keep entries dated; move shipped items into the reference docs.
     (peak/mean CS, SG, PWM during a move) so the friction/balance/homing-time
     metrics come off the firmware clock instead of host `ST` sampling; plus a
     `PING`/`PONG` link-health command for `test system link`.
-  - ⚠️ **This collides with AVR flash headroom.** Three new commands are the
-    kind of growth the ATmega32U4 no longer has room for — it sits at **79.8 %
-    of its 28 KB** (5828 B free, measured 2026-09-23), up from 19254 B at the
-    phase 2 gate. The RP2040 is a non-issue at 0.6 % of 8 MB. So either these
-    land RP2040-only behind the `platform_*.h` split, or the Delta fleet gets a
-    deliberate answer on flash first — `PROGMEM` for the string tables, dropping
-    a command, or accepting that the Delta is feature-frozen. Note §14 of the
-    config plan *cost* 222 B rather than freeing any, so the obvious saving has
-    already been spent. See [hardware-porting-plan.md](hardware-porting-plan.md).
 
 ## Planned components & integrations
 

docs/test-command.md

@@ -54,7 +54,7 @@ While a test runs, interfering commands (moves, homing, a second test, capture,
 | `host` | `memory` | available RAM / swap (`/proc/meminfo`) |
 | `host` | `load` | load average vs CPU count |
 | `hardware` | `axes` | the axes `[Hardware] axes` declares appear in telemetry, **and no others** |
-| `hardware` | `motor` | `DUMP` echoes **everything** `hardware.ini` declares — current, `steps_per_rev`, `enc_deviation`, `sw_mode` and all three speeds — catching a stale flash, a lost `SET`, or an axis that never left `NEEDCFG`. Also checks the axis is not on the firmware's **limp-home** fallback, which `USE DEFAULTS` leaves looking fully configured |
+| `hardware` | `motor` | `DUMP` echoes **everything** `hardware.ini` declares — current, `steps_per_rev`, `enc_deviation`, `sw_mode` and all three speeds — catching a stale flash, a lost `SET`, or an axis that never left `NEEDCFG` |
 | `hardware` | `imu` | a declared IMU is connected and a sample arrives |
 | `hardware` | `env` | a declared ambient sensor sits on a **real I2C** adapter (not SMBus-only) and returns a CRC-valid reading |
 | `hardware` | `camera` | every configured camera opened; `usbfs_memory_mb` and USB3 LPM hold |
@@ -99,21 +99,12 @@ Three rules hold across every leaf:
   look identical from the sensor's side, and the distinction is what
   known-issues #2 cost to learn.
 
-The `motor` leaf reports three metrics per axis. `<axis>_not_limp` asks where the
+The `motor` leaf reports two metrics per axis. `<axis>_current` covers
-values came from; `<axis>_current` covers `GLOBALSCALER`/`IRUN`/`homing IRUN`; and
+`GLOBALSCALER`/`IRUN`/`homing IRUN`; `<axis>_declared` covers everything else the
-`<axis>_declared` covers everything else the host owns. All three treat an
+host owns. Both treat an **absent** field as unconfirmable rather than as a
-**absent** field as unconfirmable rather than as a mismatch — comparing against a
+mismatch — comparing against a missing value would report "firmware has -1", which
-missing value would report "firmware has -1", which reads as a wrong setting and
+reads as a wrong setting and sends someone to re-send a command that was never the
-sends someone to re-send a command that was never the problem.
+problem.
-
-`<axis>_not_limp` runs first because it explains the other two. `USE DEFAULTS` is
-the deliberate bench escape from `NEEDCFG`, and it fills the firmware's `cfg_rx`
-mask completely — so an axis running limp-home values leaves `NEEDCFG`, reports
-`READY`, and passes every state check while running numbers that describe no real
-drivetrain. Without this metric the only symptom is `<axis>_declared` listing six
-mismatches, which reads as "host and firmware disagree" and sends someone to
-re-send values that were never sent at all. The fix is a host restart, which
-re-sends the whole declared block.
 
 The `motor` leaf is the one worth running after every flash: `GLOBALSCALER` and
 `IRUN` are **write-only** on the TMC5160, so the `DUMP` echo is the only evidence

docs/tower-installation.md

@@ -360,17 +360,10 @@ SERIAL_PORT=/dev/serial/by-id/usb-...
 ./deploy.sh --monitor          # watch it boot
 ```
 
-**Confirm the pin map before flashing a board that is wired to motors.** A
+**Confirm the pin map before flashing a board that is wired to motors.** The map
-chip-select on the wrong pin writes into a driver that was never meant to hear
+lives in `src/platform_iota.h` and a chip-select on the wrong pin writes into a
-it. The pins are the `[Pins]` section of this tower's `hardware.ini`: the build
+driver that was never meant to hear it. The numbers there are the loom as built
-reads them from `/etc/fire_gimbal_control/hardware.ini` (`firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py`)
+on tower 121, which is **not** the map proposed in the porting plan.
-and **fails without them**, so add the section before the first build. The
-reference loom, with the table saying which wire goes where, is
-[`hardware/lattepanda-iota/pins.ini`](../hardware/lattepanda-iota/pins.ini) -
-the loom as built on tower 121, which is **not** the map proposed in the porting
-plan. Copy it in if the tower is wired the same way. The generator refuses pins
-SPI0 cannot reach, and `test hardware motor` compares the declared pins with the
-ones the running firmware reports it was built with.
 
 ### Getting a factory board to accept its first flash
 

hardware/lattepanda-3-delta/pins.ini

@@ -1,17 +0,0 @@
-; The reference loom for a LattePanda 3 Delta tower: ATmega32U4 (Leonardo) ->
-; two TMC5160 driver boards, yaw and pitch.
-;
-; NOT TRANSCRIBED FROM A TOWER. These are the numbers the firmware carried in
-; src/platform_leonardo.h before pins moved into hardware.ini, which is what
-; the Delta fleet has been running on. Nobody has yet traced the loom on a Delta
-; the way tower 121's was traced, so there is no pin -> driver-pin table here.
-; Check it against tower 111 and replace this paragraph with the table.
-;
-; SPI is on the ICSP header (MISO 14, SCK 15, MOSI 16), fixed by the hardware,
-; so there are no spi_* keys; firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py refuses them, and
-; refuses 14-17 as a chip-select or enable.
-[Pins]
-yaw_cs   = 8
-yaw_en   = 7
-pitch_cs = 1
-pitch_en = 0

hardware/lattepanda-iota/pins.ini

@@ -1,27 +0,0 @@
-; The reference loom for a LattePanda IOTA tower: RP2040 -> one TMC5160-BOB.
-; AS BUILT on tower 10.11.12.121, transcribed 2026-09-15. Not the map proposed
-; in docs/hardware-porting-plan.md section 2 - that one was never wired.
-;
-;   IOTA   Function          TMC5160-BOB
-;   3.3V   logic supply      pin 1  VCC_IO  (3.3 V: the RP2040 is NOT 5 V tolerant)
-;   GND    signal ground     pin 2  GND
-;   GP1    SPI chip select   pin 3  CSN
-;   GP2    SPI clock         pin 4  SCK
-;   GP3    SPI MOSI          pin 5  SDI
-;   GP0    SPI MISO          pin 6  SDO
-;   GP4    driver enable     pin 9  DRV_ENN
-;
-; The SPI pins are not a free choice. The firmware drives SPI0, which reaches
-; SCK {2,6,18,22}, MOSI {3,7,19,23}, MISO {0,4,16,20} and nothing else;
-; firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py refuses anything outside those at build time.
-; GP1 is SPI0's hardware CSn, though the driver toggles it in software anyway.
-;
-; The installer copies this block into hardware.ini when the tower is wired to
-; this loom. A tower wired differently gets its own numbers - and the comments
-; beside them should then say what each wire really goes to.
-[Pins]
-spi_sck  = 2      ; -> BOB pin 4 SCK
-spi_mosi = 3      ; -> BOB pin 5 SDI
-spi_miso = 0      ; -> BOB pin 6 SDO
-yaw_cs   = 1      ; -> BOB pin 3 CSN
-yaw_en   = 4      ; -> BOB pin 9 DRV_ENN

include/fgc/Config.h

@@ -48,18 +48,6 @@ struct HardwareConfig {
     // Where it came from, for logging and for `test hardware` to cite.
     std::string source_path;
 
-    // [Pins] - how the MCU is wired to each driver board. The host never sends
-    // these: the firmware is BUILT from them (firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py reads
-    // the same file on the tower). Held here only so `test hardware motor` can
-    // compare them with the pins the running firmware reports it was built with.
-    // -1 = not declared.
-    struct Pins {
-        long yaw_cs = -1, yaw_en = -1, pitch_cs = -1, pitch_en = -1;
-        long spi_sck = -1, spi_mosi = -1, spi_miso = -1;  // RP2040 only
-        bool declared() const { return yaw_cs >= 0 || yaw_en >= 0 || pitch_cs >= 0 ||
-                                       pitch_en >= 0 || spi_sck >= 0; }
-    } pins;
-
     // True when `name` is listed in axes. An UNDECLARED rig answers true for
     // everything: with nothing stated there is nothing to contradict, and callers
     // must keep behaving exactly as they did before.

include/fgc/DumpParser.h

@@ -42,15 +42,6 @@ struct DumpAxis {
     // Bitmask over the firmware's CfgKey: which required keys have arrived.
     // -1 when absent.
     long        cfg_received  = -1;
-    // Is the axis running the firmware's limp-home fallback rather than anything
-    // this host declared? USE DEFAULTS fills cfg_received with the whole required
-    // mask, so that field alone cannot tell the two apart - a bench board reads as
-    // fully configured. -1 when absent, i.e. a firmware predating the flag.
-    long        limp_home     = -1;
-    // The chip-select and enable pins the running image was BUILT with. -1 when
-    // absent, i.e. a firmware that predates the pin echo.
-    long        cs_pin        = -1;
-    long        en_pin        = -1;
     // Encoder-tracking health accumulated by the firmware hold corrector.
     long        hold_corrections = 0;     // # of hold resyncs since firmware boot/RESET
     long        hold_peak_dev = 0;        // largest deviation seen while holding (counts)
@@ -89,9 +80,6 @@ struct DumpData {
     unsigned                 mcusr = 0;
     std::string              reset_text;   // empty => firmware did not name it
     long                     free_ram = 0;
-    // SPI pins the image was built with - RP2040 only, where they are a choice.
-    // -1 when absent: a Leonardo, or firmware predating the echo.
-    long                     spi_sck = -1, spi_mosi = -1, spi_miso = -1;
     std::vector<std::string> reset_flags;
     std::vector<DumpAxis>    axes;
 };

include/fgc/HardwareChecks.h

@@ -88,36 +88,6 @@ struct DrivetrainEcho {
 CheckResult checkDrivetrainAdopted(const std::string& axis, const DrivetrainExpectation& want,
                                    const DrivetrainEcho& got);
 
-// Is the axis running the host's configuration, or the firmware's limp-home
-// fallback?
-//
-// `USE DEFAULTS` is the deliberate bench escape from NEEDCFG, and it fills the
-// firmware's cfg_rx mask completely - so an axis on limp-home values reports as
-// fully configured and passes every state check. What gives it away is the DUMP
-// `limp` flag, which says where the values came from rather than whether they
-// arrived.
-//
-// checkDeclaredValues() would also catch this, but only as a list of mismatched
-// numbers, which reads as "the host and firmware disagree" and sends someone to
-// re-send them. The truthful diagnosis is that nobody ever sent any.
-//
-// `limp` < 0 means the firmware predates the flag: reported as not-run, because
-// an old firmware is a version skew rather than a misconfigured tower.
-CheckResult checkNotLimpHome(const std::string& axis, long limp);
-
-// Is the running firmware built from the wiring hardware.ini declares?
-//
-// Pins are not sent over the wire: firmware/tools/gen_wiring.py compiles them in
-// from the tower's hardware.ini [Pins]. So a mismatch never means a lost SET -
-// it means the image was built from a different copy of that file, and the fix
-// is to rebuild and re-flash. The firmware drives whatever pins it was built
-// with, which on a tower wired differently means a chip-select into a driver
-// that was never meant to hear it.
-//
-// Same shape as checkDeclaredValues: `want` false = not declared, `got` -1 =
-// not echoed, i.e. a firmware predating the pin echo.
-CheckResult checkPinsBuilt(const std::string& label, const DeclaredValue* values, int count);
-
 // Does the homed travel fit entirely in positive counts?
 //
 // `center_count` defines where the middle of the found travel sits, so the range

include/fgc/mock/MockMotorController.h

@@ -1,6 +1,5 @@
 #pragma once
 
-#include "fgc/Config.h"
 #include "fgc/IMotorController.h"
 #include "fgc/Logger.h"
 
@@ -29,14 +28,6 @@ public:
     // way the handshake is exercised on a dev box with no rig.
     explicit MockMotorController(bool needcfg = false) : needcfg_(needcfg) {}
 
-    // The pins a real image would have been built with, from hardware.ini
-    // [Pins]. Echoed in DUMP in NEEDCFG mode only, which is the mock's stand-in
-    // for current firmware; the plain mode is a firmware predating the echo.
-    void setBuiltPins(const HardwareConfig::Pins& p) {
-        std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(mutex_);
-        pins_ = p;
-    }
-
     void start() override {
         LOG_INFO << "[mock] motor controller started";
         if (!needcfg_) return;
@@ -124,10 +115,7 @@ public:
             // their meanings. See motor.h.
             const int st = (needcfg_ && !configured_) ? 5 : (homed_ ? 3 : 1);
             std::ostringstream d;
-            d << "DUMP BEGIN build=mock uptime=0 mcusr=0x01 free_ram=4096";
+            d << "DUMP BEGIN build=mock uptime=0 mcusr=0x01 free_ram=4096\n";
-            if (needcfg_ && pins_.spi_sck >= 0)
-                d << " spi=" << pins_.spi_sck << "," << pins_.spi_mosi << "," << pins_.spi_miso;
-            d << "\n";
             auto axis = [&](char L, const AxisTelemetry& a) {
                 // In NEEDCFG mode, echo back what the host actually SET, so the
                 // whole round trip - NEED, SET, DUMP, `test hardware motor` -
@@ -157,11 +145,7 @@ public:
                   << " hsub=0 enabled=" << (homed_ ? 1 : 0)
                   << " lim_neg=0 lim_pos=1000000 hold_target=" << a.xenc
                   << owned
-                  << " hold_corr=0 hold_peak=0 hold_cumul=0 has_encoder=1";
+                  << " hold_corr=0 hold_peak=0 hold_cumul=0 has_encoder=1\n";
-                const long cs = L == 'Y' ? pins_.yaw_cs : pins_.pitch_cs;
-                const long en = L == 'Y' ? pins_.yaw_en : pins_.pitch_en;
-                if (needcfg_ && cs >= 0) d << " cs=" << cs << " en=" << en;
-                d << "\n";
                 d << "DUMP " << L << " TMC GCONF=0x00000004 GSTAT=0x00000000"
                   << " IOIN=0x30000008 TSTEP=0x000fffff RAMPMODE=0x00000000"
                   << " XACTUAL=0x" << std::hex << (a.xactual & 0xffffffff)
@@ -243,7 +227,6 @@ public:
 
 private:
     bool                     needcfg_ = false;
-    HardwareConfig::Pins     pins_;
     bool                     configured_ = false;
     std::vector<std::string> need_lines_;
     std::map<std::string, std::string> settings_;

src/core/Application.cpp

@@ -306,11 +306,7 @@ struct Application::Impl {
 
     std::unique_ptr<IMotorController> makeMotor() {
         bool mock = opts.mock_serial.value_or(cfg.features.mock_serial);
-        if (mock) {
+        if (mock) return std::make_unique<MockMotorController>(cfg.features.mock_needcfg);
-            auto m = std::make_unique<MockMotorController>(cfg.features.mock_needcfg);
-            m->setBuiltPins(cfg.hardware.pins);
-            return m;
-        }
         return std::make_unique<SerialMotorController>(cfg.serial.device, cfg.serial.baud);
     }
 

src/core/Config.cpp

@@ -246,16 +246,6 @@ AppConfig ConfigLoader::fromMap(const std::map<std::string, std::string>& kv) {
     cfg.hardware.cameras = splitList(get(kv, "Hardware.cameras"));
     cfg.hardware.imu     = lowered(get(kv, "Hardware.imu"));
     cfg.hardware.env     = lowered(get(kv, "Hardware.env"));
-    {
-        auto& p = cfg.hardware.pins;
-        p.yaw_cs   = getInt(kv, "Pins.yaw_cs", -1);
-        p.yaw_en   = getInt(kv, "Pins.yaw_en", -1);
-        p.pitch_cs = getInt(kv, "Pins.pitch_cs", -1);
-        p.pitch_en = getInt(kv, "Pins.pitch_en", -1);
-        p.spi_sck  = getInt(kv, "Pins.spi_sck", -1);
-        p.spi_mosi = getInt(kv, "Pins.spi_mosi", -1);
-        p.spi_miso = getInt(kv, "Pins.spi_miso", -1);
-    }
     for (const auto& a : cfg.hardware.axes)
         if (a != "yaw" && a != "pitch")
             throw std::runtime_error("Hardware.axes: unknown axis '" + a +

src/core/DumpParser.cpp

@@ -1,7 +1,6 @@
 #include "fgc/DumpParser.h"
 
 #include <array>
-#include <cstdio>
 #include <sstream>
 #include <utility>
 
@@ -121,15 +120,6 @@ DumpData parseDump(const std::string& block) {
     d.mcusr      = static_cast<unsigned>(asInt(get(hdr, "mcusr", "0")));
     d.free_ram   = asInt(get(hdr, "free_ram", "0"));
     d.reset_text  = get(hdr, "reset");
-    {
-        // "spi=<sck>,<mosi>,<miso>". All three or none: a partial triple is a
-        // garbled line, and reporting two real pins beside a -1 would mislead.
-        const std::string spi = get(hdr, "spi");
-        long v[3];
-        if (std::sscanf(spi.c_str(), "%ld,%ld,%ld", &v[0], &v[1], &v[2]) == 3) {
-            d.spi_sck = v[0]; d.spi_mosi = v[1]; d.spi_miso = v[2];
-        }
-    }
     d.reset_flags = bitsSet(d.mcusr, kMcusr);
 
     // Per-axis lines: "DUMP <Y|P> state=.." and "DUMP <Y|P> TMC ..".
@@ -186,9 +176,6 @@ DumpData parseDump(const std::string& block) {
             ax.center_speed    = asInt(get(m, "center_speed", "-1"));
             ax.sw_mode         = asInt(get(m, "sw_mode", "-1"));
             ax.cfg_received    = asInt(get(m, "cfg_rx", "-1"), -1);
-            ax.limp_home       = asInt(get(m, "limp", "-1"), -1);
-            ax.cs_pin          = asInt(get(m, "cs", "-1"), -1);
-            ax.en_pin          = asInt(get(m, "en", "-1"), -1);
             ax.hold_corrections    = asInt(get(m, "hold_corr", "0"));
             ax.hold_peak_dev       = asInt(get(m, "hold_peak", "0"));
             ax.hold_cumulative_dev = asInt(get(m, "hold_cumul", "0"));
@@ -235,11 +222,6 @@ std::vector<std::string> formatDump(const DumpData& d) {
                << "  limits=[" << ax.lim_neg << ".." << ax.lim_pos << "]"
                << "  hold_target=" << ax.hold_target
                << "  has_encoder=" << (ax.has_encoder ? 1 : 0);
-            if (ax.cs_pin >= 0) os << "  cs=" << ax.cs_pin << " en=" << ax.en_pin;
-            // Shown only when set. It is a fault on a tower - the axis is on the
-            // firmware's fallback values, not hardware.ini's - and printing
-            // "limp=0" on every healthy dump would bury it.
-            if (ax.limp_home > 0) os << "  LIMP-HOME (not hardware.ini's values)";
             out.push_back(os.str());
         }
         for (const char* k : {"GCONF", "CHOPCONF", "XACTUAL", "X_ENC", "XTARGET", "VACTUAL"}) {

src/core/HardwareChecks.cpp

@@ -79,28 +79,6 @@ CheckResult checkI2cFunctionality(unsigned long funcs) {
     return r;
 }
 
-CheckResult checkNotLimpHome(const std::string& axis, long limp) {
-    CheckResult r;
-
-    if (limp < 0) {
-        r.ran    = false;
-        r.detail = axis +
-                   ": firmware does not report the limp flag, so whether it is running "
-                   "hardware.ini's values or its own fallback cannot be told apart here";
-        return r;
-    }
-
-    r.pass = (limp == 0);
-    r.detail = r.pass
-                   ? axis + ": running the host's declared values"
-                   : axis +
-                         ": running LIMP-HOME values, which describe no real drivetrain -- slow "
-                         "speeds, a reduced search current and a placeholder travel. Something "
-                         "sent USE DEFAULTS, so hardware.ini is NOT in force however healthy the "
-                         "axis looks. Restart the host to re-send it";
-    return r;
-}
-
 CheckResult checkDrivetrainAdopted(const std::string& axis, const DrivetrainExpectation& want,
                                    const DrivetrainEcho& got) {
     CheckResult r;
@@ -206,43 +184,6 @@ CheckResult checkDeclaredValues(const std::string& axis, const DeclaredValue* va
     return r;
 }
 
-CheckResult checkPinsBuilt(const std::string& label, const DeclaredValue* values, int count) {
-    CheckResult r;
-    int checked = 0, absent = 0;
-    std::string diff;
-    for (int i = 0; i < count; ++i) {
-        const DeclaredValue& v = values[i];
-        if (!v.want) continue;
-        if (v.got < 0) { ++absent; continue; }
-        ++checked;
-        if (v.got != v.value) {
-            if (!diff.empty()) diff += ", ";
-            diff += std::string(v.name) + " declared " + std::to_string(v.value) +
-                    ", built with " + std::to_string(v.got);
-        }
-    }
-    if (checked == 0 && absent == 0) {
-        r.ran    = false;
-        r.detail = label + ": no [Pins] declared";
-        return r;
-    }
-    if (!diff.empty()) {
-        r.pass   = false;
-        r.detail = label + ": " + diff +
-                   " -- the firmware was built from different wiring than hardware.ini "
-                   "declares. Rebuild and re-flash it";
-        return r;
-    }
-    if (absent > 0) {
-        r.pass   = false;
-        r.detail = label + ": the firmware does not report the pins it was built with, so its "
-                   "wiring cannot be confirmed -- it predates the pin echo. Re-flash it";
-        return r;
-    }
-    r.detail = label + ": built with the declared pins";
-    return r;
-}
-
 CheckResult checkTravelFitsPositive(const std::string& axis, long center, long half_travel) {
     CheckResult r;
     if (half_travel <= 0) {

src/core/TestRunner.cpp

@@ -828,7 +828,6 @@ long echoSwMode(const DumpData& d, char c)       { return axisField(d, c, &DumpA
 long echoHomingSpeed(const DumpData& d, char c)  { return axisField(d, c, &DumpAxis::homing_speed); }
 long echoCenterSpeed(const DumpData& d, char c)  { return axisField(d, c, &DumpAxis::center_speed); }
 long echoSpeed(const DumpData& d, char c)        { return axisField(d, c, &DumpAxis::speed); }
-long echoLimp(const DumpData& d, char c)         { return axisField(d, c, &DumpAxis::limp_home); }
 
 // The VMAX a declared deg/s becomes on this axis, or 0 when it cannot be formed.
 // Mirrors Application's fallback: the live calibration when it is trustworthy,
@@ -926,12 +925,6 @@ void TestRunner::testHwMotor(TestReport& r) {
     }
 
     auto check_axis = [&](const char* name, char code, const AxisDrivetrainConfig& cfg) {
-        // First, because it explains the rest. An axis on limp-home values will
-        // fail every comparison below, and that list of mismatched numbers reads
-        // as "host and firmware disagree" - sending someone to re-send values
-        // that were never sent at all.
-        verdict(s, std::string(name) + "_not_limp", checkNotLimpHome(name, echoLimp(d, code)));
-
         DrivetrainExpectation want;
         if (cfg.run_current_ma > 0.0 && cfg.r_sense_ohm > 0.0) {
             const auto plan = planTmcCurrent(cfg.r_sense_ohm, cfg.run_current_ma,
@@ -969,35 +962,10 @@ void TestRunner::testHwMotor(TestReport& r) {
         };
         verdict(s, std::string(name) + "_declared",
                 checkDeclaredValues(name, vals, (int)(sizeof(vals) / sizeof(vals[0]))));
-
-        // The wiring the image was built from, which no SET can change.
-        if (hw_.declared) {
-            const auto& p  = hw_.declared->pins;
-            const bool yaw = code == 'Y';
-            long cs = -1, en = -1;
-            for (const auto& ax : d.axes)
-                if (ax.axis == code) { cs = ax.cs_pin; en = ax.en_pin; }
-            const DeclaredValue pins[] = {
-                {"cs", (yaw ? p.yaw_cs : p.pitch_cs) >= 0, yaw ? p.yaw_cs : p.pitch_cs, cs},
-                {"en", (yaw ? p.yaw_en : p.pitch_en) >= 0, yaw ? p.yaw_en : p.pitch_en, en},
-            };
-            verdict(s, std::string(name) + "_pins", checkPinsBuilt(name, pins, 2));
-        }
     };
     check_axis("yaw", 'Y', hw_.drive->yaw);
     if (!hw_.declared || hw_.declared->hasAxis("pitch")) check_axis("pitch", 'P', hw_.drive->pitch);
 
-    // SPI is a choice only on the RP2040, so only there is it declared and echoed.
-    if (hw_.declared && hw_.declared->pins.spi_sck >= 0) {
-        const auto& p = hw_.declared->pins;
-        const DeclaredValue spi[] = {
-            {"spi_sck",  true, p.spi_sck,  d.spi_sck},
-            {"spi_mosi", p.spi_mosi >= 0, p.spi_mosi, d.spi_mosi},
-            {"spi_miso", p.spi_miso >= 0, p.spi_miso, d.spi_miso},
-        };
-        verdict(s, "spi_pins", checkPinsBuilt("spi", spi, 3));
-    }
-
     rollup(s);
     r.sections.push_back(std::move(s));
 }

tests/test_config.cpp

@@ -582,25 +582,6 @@ TEST_CASE("Hardware.axes parsing and membership") {
     }
 }
 
-TEST_CASE("[Pins] is read for comparison, and absent reads as undeclared") {
-    auto c = ConfigLoader::fromMap({{"Camera.rgb.id", "D"},
-                                    {"Camera.rgb.profile_dir", "/tmp/p"},
-                                    {"Pins.yaw_cs", "1"},
-                                    {"Pins.yaw_en", "4"},
-                                    {"Pins.spi_sck", "2"},
-                                    {"Pins.spi_miso", "0"}});
-    CHECK(c.hardware.pins.declared());
-    CHECK(c.hardware.pins.yaw_cs == 1);
-    CHECK(c.hardware.pins.yaw_en == 4);
-    CHECK(c.hardware.pins.spi_sck == 2);
-    CHECK(c.hardware.pins.spi_miso == 0);    // GP0 is a pin, not "unset"
-    CHECK(c.hardware.pins.pitch_cs == -1);
-
-    auto none = ConfigLoader::fromMap({{"Camera.rgb.id", "D"},
-                                       {"Camera.rgb.profile_dir", "/tmp/p"}});
-    CHECK_FALSE(none.hardware.pins.declared());
-}
-
 TEST_CASE("A mount angle that cannot be a rotation is rejected") {
     auto with = [](const std::string& k, const std::string& v) {
         return ConfigLoader::fromMap({{"Camera.rgb.id", "D"},

tests/test_dumpparser.cpp

@@ -1,7 +1,6 @@
 #include <doctest/doctest.h>
 
 #include "fgc/DumpParser.h"
-#include "fgc/mock/MockMotorController.h"
 
 #include <algorithm>
 #include <string>
@@ -261,61 +260,3 @@ TEST_CASE("without that field the AVR decode is labelled as an assumption") {
     CHECK(out.find("PORF") != std::string::npos);      // still decoded
     CHECK(out.find("assumed AVR") != std::string::npos);  // but not stated as fact
 }
-
-TEST_CASE("the pins the firmware was built with are read back from DUMP") {
-    const std::string text =
-        "DUMP BEGIN build=abc uptime=1 mcusr=0x3 reset=soft free_ram=4096 spi=2,3,0\n"
-        "DUMP Y state=2 hsub=0 enabled=1 lim_neg=0 lim_pos=1000000 hold_target=0 speed=1 "
-        "center=500000 soft_margin=5000 hold_corr=0 hold_peak=0 hold_cumul=0 has_encoder=1 "
-        "cs=1 en=4\n"
-        "DUMP END\n";
-    auto d = fgc::parseDump(text);
-    REQUIRE(d.valid);
-    CHECK(d.spi_sck == 2);
-    CHECK(d.spi_mosi == 3);
-    CHECK(d.spi_miso == 0);   // GP0 is a real pin, not "absent"
-    REQUIRE(d.axes.size() == 1);
-    CHECK(d.axes[0].cs_pin == 1);
-    CHECK(d.axes[0].en_pin == 4);
-    CHECK(d.axes[0].has_encoder);   // no longer the last field, still parsed
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("a firmware predating the pin echo reports -1, and a Leonardo has no spi") {
-    auto d = fgc::parseDump(kDump);
-    REQUIRE(d.valid);
-    CHECK(d.spi_sck == -1);
-    CHECK(d.spi_miso == -1);
-    for (const auto& a : d.axes) {
-        CHECK(a.cs_pin == -1);
-        CHECK(a.en_pin == -1);
-    }
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("a garbled spi triple is absent, not half-read") {
-    auto d = fgc::parseDump("DUMP BEGIN build=x uptime=1 mcusr=0x0 free_ram=1 spi=2,3\nDUMP END\n");
-    REQUIRE(d.valid);
-    CHECK(d.spi_sck == -1);
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("the mock echoes declared pins only when standing in for current firmware") {
-    fgc::HardwareConfig::Pins p;
-    p.yaw_cs = 1; p.yaw_en = 4; p.spi_sck = 2; p.spi_mosi = 3; p.spi_miso = 0;
-
-    fgc::MockMotorController current(/*needcfg=*/true);
-    current.setBuiltPins(p);
-    current.sendCommand("DUMP");
-    auto d = fgc::parseDump(current.lastDump());
-    REQUIRE(d.valid);
-    CHECK(d.spi_sck == 2);
-    CHECK(d.axes.at(0).cs_pin == 1);
-    CHECK(d.axes.at(0).en_pin == 4);
-    CHECK(d.axes.at(1).cs_pin == -1);   // no pitch pins declared
-
-    fgc::MockMotorController old;       // predates the echo, as real old firmware does
-    old.setBuiltPins(p);
-    old.sendCommand("DUMP");
-    auto o = fgc::parseDump(old.lastDump());
-    REQUIRE(o.valid);
-    CHECK(o.spi_sck == -1);
-    CHECK(o.axes.at(0).cs_pin == -1);
-}

tests/test_hardwarechecks.cpp

@@ -41,35 +41,6 @@ TEST_CASE("an SMBus-only adapter is caught before it looks like a dead sensor")
     CHECK(smbus.detail.find("i2cdetect -F") != std::string::npos);
 }
 
-TEST_CASE("a tower on limp-home values is a fault, however healthy it looks") {
-    // The case this exists for: USE DEFAULTS fills the firmware's cfg_rx mask
-    // completely, so the axis leaves NEEDCFG, reports READY and passes every
-    // state check - while running values that describe no real drivetrain.
-    auto r = checkNotLimpHome("yaw", 1);
-    CHECK(r.ran);
-    CHECK_FALSE(r.pass);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("LIMP-HOME") != std::string::npos);
-    // It must send the reader to the cause, not to the symptom. "Re-send the
-    // values" is the wrong instruction when nobody ever sent any.
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("USE DEFAULTS") != std::string::npos);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("Restart the host") != std::string::npos);
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("an axis on the host's own values passes") {
-    auto r = checkNotLimpHome("yaw", 0);
-    CHECK(r.ran);
-    CHECK(r.pass);
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("a firmware with no limp flag is a version skew, not a passing tower") {
-    // Absent must not read as limp=0. A firmware predating the flag genuinely
-    // cannot answer the question, and claiming PASS here would assert something
-    // the wire never said - the same -1-is-not-zero rule the current echo uses.
-    auto r = checkNotLimpHome("yaw", -1);
-    CHECK_FALSE(r.ran);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("cannot be told apart") != std::string::npos);
-}
-
 TEST_CASE("an undeclared axis has no drivetrain skew to find") {
     DrivetrainExpectation want;  // declared == false
     DrivetrainEcho        got;   // all -1
@@ -250,37 +221,3 @@ TEST_CASE("an un-homed axis is not checked") {
     CHECK_FALSE(r.ran);
     CHECK(r.pass);
 }
-
-// --- the wiring the image was built from ------------------------------------
-
-TEST_CASE("pins built as declared pass") {
-    const DeclaredValue v[] = {{"cs", true, 1, 1}, {"en", true, 4, 4}};
-    auto r = checkPinsBuilt("yaw", v, 2);
-    CHECK(r.ran);
-    CHECK(r.pass);
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("a pin mismatch blames the build, not a lost SET") {
-    // Pins never travel over the wire, so "a SET was lost" would send someone
-    // looking in the wrong place. The only fix is a rebuild from this file.
-    const DeclaredValue v[] = {{"cs", true, 1, 5}, {"en", true, 4, 4}};
-    auto r = checkPinsBuilt("yaw", v, 2);
-    CHECK_FALSE(r.pass);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("cs declared 1, built with 5") != std::string::npos);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("Rebuild and re-flash") != std::string::npos);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("SET") == std::string::npos);
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("a firmware that does not echo its pins cannot pass") {
-    const DeclaredValue v[] = {{"cs", true, 1, -1}, {"en", true, 4, -1}};
-    auto r = checkPinsBuilt("yaw", v, 2);
-    CHECK(r.ran);
-    CHECK_FALSE(r.pass);
-    CHECK(r.detail.find("predates the pin echo") != std::string::npos);
-}
-
-TEST_CASE("no [Pins] declared is not checked") {
-    const DeclaredValue v[] = {{"cs", false, 0, 1}};
-    auto r = checkPinsBuilt("yaw", v, 1);
-    CHECK_FALSE(r.ran);
-}